Worse Preoperative Pain and Higher Activity Levels Predict Patient Choice of Formal Physical Therapy After Primary Anterior Total Hip Arthroplasty

The purpose of this randomized controlled trial is (1) to compare the efficacy of supervised formal physical therapy (PT) and self-directed home exercises and (2) to identify independent predictors of transitioning from self-directed home exercises to supervised formal PT following total hip arthroplasty (THA) via an anterior approach.

After Institutional Review Board approval, 147 patients undergoing primary unilateral THA through anterior approach were enrolled and randomized to receive either clinic or home-based PT. Surveys with Hip Disability Osteoarthritis Outcome Scores (HOOS) and Short Form-12 Health Survey scores for both groups were obtained before surgery and at 6, 14, and 24 weeks after surgery. Patients had the option to transition into the other study group at their 6-week follow-up visit.

Of the 147 patients enrolled, final analysis included scores for 136 patients. Forty-two (63.6%) of the 66 patients randomized to the supervised formal PT group crossed over to self-directed home exercise group and 12 (17.1%) of the 70 patients randomized to the self-directed home exercise group crossed over to supervised formal PT group. There were no significant (P > .05) differences between groups at all time points for the overall HOOS and Short Form-12 Health Survey. Subjects with worse preoperative pain scores (P = .005) and higher HOOS preoperative activity of daily living scores (P = .015) were more likely to transition from the home exercise group to formal PT group.

There were no significant outcome score differences between subjects undergoing supervised formal PT and self-directed home exercises. However, patients reporting worse preoperative pain and higher preoperative activity levels may prefer supervised formal PT compared to self-directed home exercises after undergoing primary anterior THA.