Failure of an Uncemented Press-Fit Acetabular Cup in Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty

We reviewed fifteen primary total hip replacements performed using the uncemented, non-porous coated press-fit AcSys Shearer Cup. A modular titanium straight femoral stem with a 32mm head was used in all cases. The mean age of the group containing five males and 10 females was 66 years. Eight cups have been revised for aseptic loosening at a mean of seven years and the remaining four cups are radiologically loose. At revision surgery none of the cups showed any evidence of bony ingrowth.

Our 10-year results with this cup indicate an unacceptably high failure rate of 80%. Absence of bony ingrowth and the lack of a secure locking mechanism between the polyethylene liner and the metal shell are the most important causes of failure. The use of a 32mm diameter head and implantation of the cup in an open position contributed to this failure. Even though this cup is no longer manufactured, our experience suggests that all non-porous coated cups should be closely followed up.