A Comparison of a Second- and a Third-Generation Modular Cup Design: Is New Improved?

The highly cross-linked polyethylene liners currently used with modular uncemented cups have substantially decreased wear and osteolysis at early follow-up. However, retroacetabular osteolysis has still been reported in some cases with DePuy Orthopaedic’s (Warsaw, IN) second-generation Duraloc acetabular shell. DePuy’s third-generation Pinnacle cup incorporates a different shell-liner locking mechanism. We compared the clinical outcome among a matched series of 42 Duraloc and 42 Pinnacle cups at a mean follow-up of 5.9 years. Although the Harris Hip Scores and wear rates were not statistically different between the 2 cup designs, retroacetabular osteolysis behind the central hole was absent among the Pinnacle cups but noted among 19% of the Duraloc cups.