Results of All-Polyethylene Tibial Components as a Cost-Saving Technique

Since 1992, the authors have used an all polyethylene tibial component in relatively less active patients older than 70 years of age who present for primary total knee replacement. Results of 312 knee replacements performed between March 1992 and March 1998 are presented in the hopes of showing this technique as a viable cost saving measure. Three hundred twelve primary total knee replacements were performed by the same group of surgeons. Fourteen patients died before the first year postoperative evaluation, leaving an index group of 298 knees in 231 patients. All components were evaluated using the radiographic and clinical parameters of the Knee Society. Hospital for Special Surgery scores also were calculated. All patients were given the Short Form-36 Quality of Life Assessment preoperatively and annually postoperatively. Clinical scores showed dramatic improvement. There have been three revisions (0.7%) but none were for aseptic loosening. Radiographic review revealed 295 replacements with optimum fixation. To date, no patient has osteolysis. The cost differential was significant. The use of this type of tibial component has, to date, afforded excellent clinical and radiographic results. Additional followup is needed to show the longevity of these results and to monitor wear or subsidence of these prostheses. Should these results continue to prove satisfactory in this particular group of patients with relatively low physical demands, significant cost savings may be realized.