Is the Preoperative Radiograph Useful in Predicting the Outcome of a Total Hip Replacement?

The preoperative radiographs of 1015 patients undergoing 1163 total hip replacements for osteoarthritis were evaluated to determine if a relationship exists between the extent of osteoarthritis and the clinical results of a total hip replacement. Preoperative radiographs were graded with respect to the degree of cartilage space loss, direction of cartilage space loss (femoral head migration), and severity of osteophyte formation. Followup averaged 32.1 months (range, 6-93 months). Greater degrees of cartilage space loss correlated with lower hip scores preoperatively but were unrelated to preoperative pain. These patients had statistically less pain at 6 months and 1 year. Patients with superior cartilage space loss before surgery also had statistically less pain at 6 months. However, at 3 years and beyond, pain was independent of degree of preoperative cartilage space loss, osteophyte formation, or femoral head migration. In addition, hip scores at any followup were independent of the degree of osteoarthritis observed on the preoperative radiograph. These findings provide statistical support to the concept that greater degrees of joint space loss correlate with better relief of pain and less severe joint space loss correlates with less relief of pain within the first year after total hip replacement. At 3 years and beyond, hip and pain scores were independent of the degree of preoperative osteoarthritis.